Erga omnes obligations in international environmental law rachael lorna johnstone faculty of law, university of aberdeen 9 december 20. This confusion could stem from the conflation of the consequences of a breach of an obligation erga omnes with those of a serious violation of a peremptory norm under articles 4041 arsiwa. In 2007, the international court of justice declared that states have a duty to prevent genocide from occurring in another state since the prevention and punishment of genocide is a concern of every state and of the international community as a. Inna uchkunova, new bulgarian university llm is a member of the international moot court competition association. The defensive character cannot be maintained as the respondent state cannot invoke a previous violation of its rights committed by the applicant in order to justify conduct that. Charter 72 kamrul hossain the concept of jus cogens and the obligation under the u. Some indications as to which obligations qualified as obligation erga omnes include contemporary rights of protection, including protection from slavery. Pronunciation of erga omnes with 2 audio pronunciations and more for erga omnes. What is the difference between erga omnes and jus cogens. Also ergo omnes a erga omnes law or legal act applies as against every individual, person or state without distinction for example, a judicial declaration that a certain marriage is null and void is stated to be erga omnes so that it is understood to have that status towards the world at large and not just the celebrants similarly, a statute can be struck down for constitutional. Latest developments questions relating to the obligation. If violations of obligations erga omnes did not trigger any special rights of response, the concept, at least for the purposes of law enforcement, would be of rhetorical value only.
New trends in the enforcement of erga omnes obligations. Pdf erga omnes, jus cogens and their impact on the law. An erga omnes dispute in the united nations for defining the. The concept of jus cogens the notion of peremptory norms in international law is reminiscent of the distinction in roman law between jus strictum strict law and jus dispositivum voluntary law, as well as. Les obligations et les droits erga omnes en droit international. Ten lengthy reports have been produced so far, with the most recent ones focusing on ghana, sierra leone, and vanuatu. This chapter discusses the concept of obligations erga omnes and the essential distinction between obligations erga omnes and other obligations of international law. Only the second aspect comes within the sphere of responsibility proper. Using the url or doi link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely. It has been suggested that an example of an erga omnes obligation is that of a peoples right to selfdetermination.
In general legal theory the concept erga omnes latin. Enforcing obligations erga omnes in international law christian j. This is the first monograph on the idea of obligations erga omnes, an increasingly important concept in contemporary international law. The most advanced type of this kind of obligation derives from per emptory norms of international law jus. Article 103 obligates all member states to comply with these decisions. Obligations stemming from regional or universal human rights treaties would have 9ibid.
Jan 31, 2019 the obligation of the administering state to respect and promote the right of selfdetermination of the inhabitants is not only owed visavis the inhabitants of the colonial territory, but also visavis the international community as a whole. Maurizio ragazzi employs a pragmatic approach that identifies five common elements among the examples of obligations erga omnes given by the international court. Pdf erga omnes, jus cogens and their impact on the law of. The simple truth is that the convention does not go as far as the court suggests.
The concept of obligations erga omnesobligations to the international community as a wholehas fascinated international lawyers for decades. The term is used to describe legal obligations and rights towards all. Erga omnes is most frequently found in relation to laws that involve the public and international law an erga omneslaw is one that can hold any member of the general public in. Prohibition of sexual exploitation of children constituting. It is argued that the status of the crime of genocide renders failure to. Cherif bassiouni i introduction international crimes that rise to the level of jus cogens constitute obligatio erga omnes which are inderogable. Reflections on the effectiveness of peremptory norms and. Not a standalone source of international law but a description of the character of certain international laws. Questions relating to the obligation to prosecute or. In its dictum on the barcelona traction case, the international court of justice icj, gave rise to the concept of erga omnes obligations in international law. In the context of the refugee crisis, obligation erga omnes can be extended to the obligation to eschew refoulement, as obligation erga omnes is similarly placed as non. For instance, a property right is an erga omnes entitlement, and therefore enforceable against anybody infringing that right.
Obligations erga omnes legal obligations applicable against all states. With respect to the admissibility of belgiums claims, the court ruled that once any state party to the convention against torture was able invoke the responsibility of another state party with a view to ascertaining the alleged failure to comply with its obligations erga omnes partes, i. Reflections on the effectiveness of peremptory norms and erga. Latest developments questions relating to the obligation to. Jus cogens, obligations erga omnes and other rules the identification of fundamental norms.
The classification of obligations and the multilateral dimension of. Obligations jus cogens and erga omnes, and their impact on universal jurisdiction michelle knorr abstract this paper explores the nature of the obligation to prevent and punish the international crime of genocide. If the inline pdf is not rendering correctly, you can download the pdf file. Thus, all peremptory norms create obligations erga omnes, but not all erga omnes obligations derive from peremptory norms. Law must be enforced in order to be effective, yet at the international level enforcement is relatively underdeveloped.
The concept of erga omnes obligations in international law. The contributions in this liber amicorum deal with questions of procedural law in an international context. Concept of international obligations erga omnes oxford. In this case, international law must strike a balance between, on the one. The judgment in the case concerning questions relating to the obligation to prosecute or extradite belgium v. The sole consequence of characterising an obligation as erga omnes is the generation of a right of standing on all states. Enforcing obligations erga omnes in international law. Erga omnes is a latin legal term that means in relation to all. In international law, the concept of erga omnes obligations refers to specifically determined obligations that states have towards the international community as a whole. New trends in the enforcement of erga omnes obligations pdf. If not yet acknowledged to be jus cogens, the obligation to protect the. In an obiter dictum in its 1970 judgment in the barcelona traction case, the international court of justice identified a category of international obligations called erga omnes, namely obligations owed by states to the international community as a whole, intended to protect and promote the basic values and common interests of all. The concept of jus cogens and the obligation under the u.
Some indications as to which obligations qualified as obligation erga omnes include contemporary rights of protection, including. Legal consequences of the construction of a wall in the occupied palestinian territory, icj reports 2004, 6, sep. An erga omnes dispute in the united nations for defining. Tams the concept of obligations erga omnes obligations to the international community as a wholehas fascinated international lawyers for decades, yet its precise implications remain unclear. Both concepts deal with the binding force of rules of international law. Erga omnes obligations in international environmental law. An erga omnes right a statutory right can here be distinguished from a right based on contract, which is only enforceable. Jus cogens and obligations erga omnes oxford handbooks.
Erga omnes academic dictionaries and encyclopedias. Invoking obligations erga omnes in the twentyfirst. The right against trespass of a property can be enforced as against everyone. In so doing, it recognises that recent developments of the law of slavery has brought to life existing treaty and customary international law obligations. Whereas in ordinary obligations the defaulting state bears responsibility toward particular interested states e. Erga omnes is a latin phrase which means towards all or towards everyone. The author concludes that these conditions for the admissibility of a counterclaim cannot be fulfilled when the violation of an erga omnes obligation is alleged.
Kolb, theorie du jus cogens international 2001 33 et seq. Jus cogens and obligations erga omnes leiden et al. They cover not only problems of international civil procedure and international arbitration, but also questions of administering justice in the domestic civil and criminal law contexts, as well as in the fields of public international law and european law. Diplomatic protection and state responsibility erga omnes. Invoking obligations erga omnes in the twentyfirst century. Legal obligations which arise from the higher status of such crimes include the duty to prosecute or extradite, the non. Since the wellknown obiter dictum of the international court of justice icj in the 1970 barcelona traction judgment,1 all states have a legal interest in the implementation of erga omnes obligations. Senegal is the first in the history of the international court of justice icj in which it found that a state had standing based on. Enforcing obligations erga omnes in international law by. The aim is to identify and analyse jus cogens and obligation erga omnes in relation to the sexual exploitation of children and to evaluate the international responsibility of states in relation to the elimination or prevention of the crime, and the prosecution and punishment of offenders. For instance a property right is an erga omnes right, and therefore enforceable against anybody infringing that right. The concept of obligations erga omnes obligations to the international community as a wholehas fascinated international lawyers for decades.
Concerning the appearance of the notion of obligations erga omnes, one will recall the famous obiter. The concept of obligations erga omnes obligations to the international community as a whole has fascinated international lawyers for decades, yet its precise implications remain unclear. Orakhelashvili, peremptory norms in international law oxford, oxford university press. Thus, in the event of a breach of these obligations, every state must be considered justified in invoking probably through judicial channels the responsibility of the guilty state committing the internationally wrongful act. Invoking obligations erga omnes in the twentyfirst century 3 are thus obligations erga omnes. Without losing sight of the theoretical dimension of.
The term is in contradiction to contract law, where contract can be enforced only against a party to the contract and no other. This threshold question of whether obligatio erga omnes carries with it the full implications of the latin word obligatio, or whether it is denatured in international law to signify only the existence of a. Dinah shelton ed, the oxford handbook on human rights oup 20 forthcoming. Enforcing obligations erga omnes in international law the concept of obligations erga omnes obligations owed to the internationalcommunityasawholehasfascinatedinternational lawyers for decades, yet its precise implications remain unclear.
In language more comm on hitherto, reference is made to obligations erga omnes,2 as well as the existence of jus cogens3 and. The concept of international obligations erga omnes. The icj adapted a similar idea to the field of law enforcement, by cryptically pointing to an essential distinction between the regular obligations of a state. Counterclaims and obligations erga omnes before the. Jun 02, 20 the simple truth is that the convention does not go as far as the court suggests. This book assesses how this concept affects the enforcement of international law.
Erga omnes obligations state practice vienna convention on the law of treaties treaties, effect for third states humanitarian intervention reparation aggression countermeasures. The rights constituting obligation erga omnes are so important that it is in the interest of the international community to protect them, even if it requires intervention. Obligations erga omnes and the actio popularis springerlink. The totality of these obligations is considered, with special emphasis given to slaverys obligations erga omnes. These five properties are then discussed comparatively. It refers to rights and responsibilities that can be enforced against anyone, rather than against a specific person or party. The celebrated paragraph 33 of barcelona traction inspired the international. The decisions in the security council that give rise to a compelling obligation upon the member states are taken mostly by means of political consideration. The international responsibility of states for breach of. Erga omnes rules expand the scope of possible claimants in certain situations, to protect key common interests where traditional rules of standing are insufficient to do so. The relevance of erga omnes obligations in prosecuting. Erga omnes rules expand the scope of possible claimants in certain situa tions, to protect key common interests where traditional rules of standing. In legal terminology, erga omnes rights or obligations are owed toward all. Published under the auspices of the max planck foundation for international peace and the rule of law under the direction of rudiger wolfrum.
1194 970 683 1419 1351 438 331 342 83 523 1478 1192 441 601 248 1069 550 256 1214 19 874 1024 133 230 1183 420 1177 1492 1000 1162 96 387 564 394 807 727 795 609 366 1418 1043 756 931 586 1377 845